HR & Labor Compliance
Employee File Checklist: What Goes in a Personnel File (and What Doesn't)
The four files every employer keeps, what belongs in the personnel file, what must stay separate (medical, I-9, investigations), and the records most often missing.
Written by
Employee Documentation Experts
· 11 min read

In this guide
A personnel file holds the job-related history of one employee: application and offer letter, job description, pay changes, signed handbook acknowledgments, training records, performance reviews, dated coaching notes, written warnings, and separation documents. Medical records, Form I-9 and its supporting documents, and workplace investigation records belong in separate files with tighter access.
Most checklists stop at the hire packet, but the documents that decide a dispute are the ones a manager creates after hire: coaching notes, attendance occurrences, and write-ups. Missing records are usually those later notes, and they are often sitting in the wrong file.
An employee file checklist for a small employer names the files you keep, what goes in each, and what must stay out. Pull it out when a records request, an unemployment notice, or a new HR hire asks where the files are.
For the same-shift records that make a restaurant file useful in a hearing, use the restaurant employee documentation checklist. This page stays with a prior question: which file a record belongs in.
Every employer in this checklist keeps four files: a personnel file, a confidential medical file, one I-9 file for the whole workforce, and an investigation file. A benefits file is a common fifth file. Keeping it separate is practice, not a single statute you can cite as a filing rule.
Coaching notes and write-ups belong in the personnel file, dated and in order. If the only copy is on a manager's phone, the note is not in the file.
The four files every employer keeps
| File | What goes in it | Who can access it |
|---|---|---|
| Personnel file (one per employee) | Hiring documents, pay history, policy acknowledgments, training, reviews, dated coaching notes, discipline, separation | HR and managers who decide about that employee. Employee access depends on state law. |
| Confidential medical file (one per employee) | Doctor's notes, FMLA certifications, accommodation requests, workers' comp medical information, drug test results, and medical information the employee volunteers | Confidential, separate from the personnel file, shared only in limited circumstances |
| I-9 file (one file for all employees) | Every Form I-9, plus copies of identity or work-authorization documents if you keep copies | Whoever must present the forms if DHS, DOJ IER, or DOL inspects |
| Investigation file (one per investigation) | Complaint, witness statements, interview notes, and the report | HR, the investigator, and counsel |
| Benefits file (optional) | Enrollment forms and beneficiary designations | HR or the benefits administrator |
Audit one employee against the table. A finished hire packet does not fix a doctor's note behind the résumé or an I-9 clipped to the offer letter.
The job decision goes in the personnel file. The backup stays out. A written warning that follows an investigation belongs in the personnel file. The complaint, statements, interview notes, and report stay in the investigation file. Keeping investigation files separate, and keeping a benefits file separate, is common practice, not a statute.
Personnel file checklist

If an item exists, date it and file it under that person. If it lives only in a manager's memory, it is not in the file.
Hiring
- Application or résumé
- Offer letter
- Job description
- Exempt or non-exempt classification
File the job description they were hired into, and a dated replacement when the job changes. The offer letter should match the exempt or non-exempt classification you rely on.
Pay
- Starting rate and every change, with the date and the reason
- Form W-4 and state withholding forms
Keep each rate change, with the date and the reason, in the personnel file even when payroll calculates the check. W-4 and state withholding forms can sit in the personnel file or with payroll. Pick one place and note it here.
Policies
- Signed handbook acknowledgment, with the version or date
- At-will acknowledgment, if you use one
- Acknowledgment of each later policy update
An unsigned handbook proves you printed a rule. It does not prove the employee received it.
Training and certifications
- Training completed, with the date
- Licenses or cards the job requires, with expiration dates
File the completion date and the expiration date. Restaurant cards, where state or local rules require them, are listed below.
Performance
- Performance reviews
- Dated coaching notes
- Recognition
- Performance improvement plans
Coaching notes, recognition, and improvement plans belong here, beside the reviews. A note needs the date, who coached, and what was said. A file of warnings only is a thin story of the job.
Discipline
Verbal warnings, write-ups, and attendance belong in this file in date order. A verbal warning still needs a record of what was said: see restaurant verbal warning documentation. A written warning needs the facts and the rule: see how to write up an employee. Attendance occurrences belong here too, including ones that never became a warning: see how to document employee attendance issues.
- Verbal-warning documentation
- Written warnings
- Final warnings
- Suspension notices
- Dated attendance occurrences
- The employee's rebuttal, if they wrote one
File the warning you issued. Leave witness interviews in the investigation file. File the employee's rebuttal when they offer one.
Separation
- Resignation letter or termination notice
- Separation summary: date, reason, and the records you relied on
The summary points at records already in the file. For a restaurant separation, restaurant termination documentation shows how that summary lines up with the attendance and coaching already saved.
What to keep out of the personnel file
Medical information goes in the confidential medical file: doctor's notes, FMLA certifications, accommodation requests, workers' comp claims, drug test results, and medical details an employee volunteers. The EEOC Enforcement Guidance on Disability-Related Inquiries and Medical Examinations of Employees under the ADA says the ADA requires employers to treat that information, including information voluntarily disclosed, as a confidential medical record, kept confidential and separate from personnel records, and shared only in limited circumstances.
An attendance line in the personnel file can be a date and a call-off. The diagnosis and the doctor's note stay in the medical file. Tell a supervisor the work restriction, not the medical history.
Form I-9 does not go in the personnel file. Keep every employee's form together in one I-9 file, with copies of supporting documents if you keep copies, so you can present them without opening other folders. USCIS, Handbook for Employers M-274, section 10.0, Retaining Form I-9, says employers must be able to present Forms I-9 within three business days of an inspection request from DHS, DOJ IER, or DOL.
Investigation records stay in the investigation file. That separation is common practice, not a statute. The warning or discharge you issued still goes in the personnel file. The notes behind it do not.
EEO self-identification data stays in its own file so people making hiring, pay, and discipline decisions are not reading it during an ordinary file review. Benefits enrollment and beneficiary forms are commonly kept out of the personnel file for the same kind of reason. That, too, is practice, not a statute.
Job decisions should not be made with medical or protected-class information in view. Some records, including Forms I-9, also have to be presented quickly, which fails when they are scattered through every personnel folder.
Restaurant extras
Restaurants add a few items to the personnel file, and only where your state or local rules require them: food handler cards, alcohol server permits, tip-credit or tip-pool acknowledgments, and minor work permits for anyone under 18. File the card or acknowledgment with its expiration date, next to other training records, not in the I-9 file and not in the medical file.
Write the expiration date on a food handler card or alcohol server permit so a renewal is not a surprise in an inspection. State and city rules differ. Confirm the list with your state labor department and your local health department before you treat a missing card as a violation.
Same-shift incident notes, attendance matched to the schedule, and guest or cash events are a different checklist. Use the restaurant employee documentation checklist. This page only says which file a record belongs in.
How long to keep it
USCIS, Handbook for Employers M-274, section 10.0, Retaining Form I-9, says to retain each Form I-9 for three years after the date of hire or one year after employment ends, whichever is later. Keep it the whole time the person works. After employment ends, keep it until the later of those two dates. You must also present Forms I-9 within three business days of an inspection request from DHS, DOJ IER, or DOL.
Other retention periods vary by record type and by federal and state law. Write a retention schedule that names each record type and where it lives, and review that schedule with counsel before you destroy anything.
This page is not legal advice.
Can employees see their personnel file?
Whether an employee can inspect or copy a personnel file varies by state. Check your state labor department before you grant or refuse a request. This page names no states. The Department of Labor directory of state labor offices is a way to find that office.
A personnel-file request is not a request for the medical file or the I-9 file. Leave those on their own access rules.
The records that are usually missing
The hire packet is usually there. The gap is everything after the hire date.
Coaching that was said on the floor and never written down. Attendance that lives in a manager's head: the schedule shows the shift, not the late arrivals or the no-call, and not the conversation in between. Notes that exist only on a phone, in a group chat, or on a pad in the office, and that leave when that manager leaves.
Phone notes stay on one device. Group chat is not a file in date order. Paper files stay in one office. If a claim is already open, read how to defend an unemployment claim and answer from records you actually have.
A personnel file also holds the dated note when the issue is a no-call, no-show, tardiness, a cell phone, being rude to a guest, a dress code, leaving early, insubordination, social media, employee theft, tip theft, or a void or comp. Employee write-up examples show the shape of those notes. Employee documentation software is the system that keeps them with the file instead of in a folder.
Where Docu-Coach™ fits
Docu-Coach™ is the manager's history beside the HRIS. It does not replace the HRIS or payroll, and it does not store Form I-9 or confidential medical files. Do not put a diagnosis or an I-9 document number in a coaching note.
It keeps coaching, recognition, attendance, incidents, and follow-ups on that person's timeline, from ten-second voice notes. HR Ready compiles a chronology with source links from saved records only. That chronology is the personnel file timeline. Dated coaching and write-ups are what employee write-up software keeps on that timeline. A restaurant note that also needs the shift and the station can sit in restaurant employee write-up software.
Word and PDF exports are on Manager. You place the export into the personnel file you already keep. Teams adds role-based access, manager offboarding, and employee reassignment, so the history stays when a manager leaves.
Start a 30-day free trial, no card required. After that, Manager is $9.98/month for up to 25 people. Teams is $250/month.
This week, check three employees against the table and the checklist. Move medical papers, Forms I-9, and investigation notes out of the personnel file if they are in it. Write the next coaching note where it still exists after that manager is gone.
Frequently Asked Questions
What goes in an employee personnel file?
A personnel file holds the job-related history of one employee: application and offer letter, job description, pay changes, signed handbook acknowledgments, training records, performance reviews, dated coaching notes, written warnings, and separation documents. Medical records, Form I-9 and its supporting documents, and workplace investigation records belong in separate files with tighter access.
What should not be in a personnel file?
Medical information, including information an employee volunteers, belongs in a confidential medical file. The EEOC says the ADA requires that information to be kept confidential and separate from personnel records, and shared only in limited circumstances. Form I-9 and its supporting documents belong in one I-9 file. Investigation records belong in an investigation file. EEO self-identification data stays separate too. Keeping investigation and benefits files separate is common practice, not a statute.
Do I-9 forms go in the personnel file?
No. Keep every employee's Form I-9 together in one separate I-9 file so you can present them quickly if the government asks. USCIS says employers must be able to present Forms I-9 within three business days of an inspection request from DHS, DOJ IER, or DOL, and must retain each Form I-9 for three years after the date of hire or one year after employment ends, whichever is later.
How long do you keep personnel files and I-9s?
Retain each Form I-9 for three years after the date of hire or one year after employment ends, whichever is later, and be able to present Forms I-9 within three business days of an inspection request from DHS, DOJ IER, or DOL. Other retention periods vary by record type and by federal and state law. Use a written retention schedule and review it with counsel.
Can employees see their personnel file?
It varies by state. Some states let employees inspect or copy a personnel file, and others do not. Check your state labor department before you answer a request. Do not treat that request as permission to hand over the medical file or the I-9 file.
Where do coaching notes and write-ups belong?
In the personnel file, dated and in order. That includes coaching notes, recognition, attendance occurrences, verbal-warning documentation, written warnings, and the employee's rebuttal. A note that lives only on a manager's phone or in a group chat is not in the file.
Related Resources
Restaurant Employee Documentation Checklist
The same-shift restaurant file: acknowledgments, attendance vs the schedule, alcohol, cash, and guest complaints, ready before a hearing.
12 min read · October 2026
How to Write Up an Employee
What a write-up must include, whether the employee has to sign, and what to do if they refuse. Write it the same shift it happens.
11 min read
How to Document Employee Attendance Issues
Publish the attendance rule, log each occurrence the same shift, and apply one step to everyone. Includes what protected leave never counts.
10 min read
How to Defend an Unemployment Claim
How to Defend an Unemployment Claim for operators and HR. Step-by-step guidance, legal risk, examples, and best practices.
2 min read
Documenting a Verbal Warning
How to document a verbal warning in a restaurant: what the note must say, how it differs from coaching, and why the unwritten verbal breaks later steps.
11 min read · September 2026
Restaurant Termination Documentation
What a restaurant should have in the file before terminating: the pre-termination review, the separation summary, property and access checklist, and how to run the conversation.
6 min read · September 2026